Understanding guilt in relationship breakups

Relationships are intricate and often mired in complex emotions. It's not uncommon for people to experience guilt when they contemplate leaving a relationship, even when staying is no longer fulfilling or healthy. The root of this guilt often lies in societal expectations, promises made, and a genuine concern for the other person's feelings. But sometimes, it's driven by the fear of loneliness and the comfort of the safety net the relationship provides.


Understanding the guilt

1. Commitment and promises

Commitment is a cornerstone of relationships, and when we commit to someone, we tend to take that commitment seriously. Breaking promises or vows made to a partner can elicit feelings of guilt. This is especially true when external pressures emphasise the importance of keeping one's word.

2. Fear of hurting the other person

It's natural to care deeply for your partner and not want to cause them pain. The thought of causing emotional distress or upheaval in their life can trigger guilt. This emotional connection often makes the decision to leave difficult.

3. External expectations

Society, family, and friends can exert pressure on individuals to stay in relationships, even when they're unhappy. The fear of judgment and the belief that relationships should withstand all challenges can lead to feelings of guilt.

4. Investment of time and effort

Relationships demand time and effort. When you've invested years or even decades in a partnership, the idea of 'wasting' that investment by leaving can generate guilt. It's the sunk cost fallacy in emotional form.

5. Perceived responsibility

Some individuals take on the role of the caretaker in their relationships. They feel a sense of responsibility for their partner's well-being and feel guilty about abandoning them, especially if their partner is emotionally or financially dependent.

Recognising the safety net trap

1. Fear of loneliness

Loneliness can be a powerful motivator for staying in a relationship. The prospect of being alone, with no one to share life's ups and downs, can be a terrifying thought. This fear can become a safety net that keeps you from leaving, even when you're not happy in the relationship.

2. Dependency on the relationship

Whether it's financial, emotional, or logistical, dependencies on the relationship can create a safety net. The fear of losing the security and stability the relationship provides can be paralysing.

3. Low self-esteem

If your self-esteem is intrinsically tied to the relationship, leaving can feel like it would devalue you as a person. Staying becomes a means to preserve your self-worth, even when the relationship isn't fulfilling.

4. Unfulfilling relationship

When a relationship no longer fulfils your emotional or personal needs, but you stay primarily to avoid being alone, you're ensnared in the safety net trap. The relationship becomes a source of security, but it's devoid of genuine love or connection.

5. Comfort zone

Many people resist change, and leaving a relationship can be a significant upheaval. Staying in your comfort zone, even if it's not making you happy, can feel easier than facing the uncertainty of life outside the relationship.

6. Lack of autonomy

Feeling incapable of functioning or making decisions independently can lead to staying in a relationship out of fear of being alone. This dependency can be suffocating, making it challenging to break free.

Breaking free and seeking help

Recognising these signs is the first step towards addressing the situation. While guilt is a natural emotion in relationship breakups, it's essential to prioritise your well-being and happiness. Seek support from a therapist or counsellor to navigate the complex emotions tied to leaving a relationship and facing the fear of being alone. A trained professional can provide guidance, offer coping strategies, and help you build the emotional resilience needed to move forward.

Ultimately, breaking free from the safety net trap is an act of self-care and empowerment. It's about acknowledging your worth and recognising that you deserve a relationship that fulfils you, rather than one that merely provides a sense of security. Life outside of the safety net can be uncertain, but it also holds the promise of personal growth, newfound independence, and the opportunity to build healthier, more fulfilling relationships in the future.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author. All articles published on Counselling Directory are reviewed by our editorial team.

Share this article with a friend
Wantage OX12 & Rickmansworth WD3
Written by Hope Therapy & Counselling Services, Offering Counselling, CBT, Hypnotherapy, EMDR & Mindfulness.
Wantage OX12 & Rickmansworth WD3

Ian Stockbridge is the founder and lead counsellor at Hope Therapy and Counselling Services. 

As an experienced Counsellor, Ian recognised a huge societal need for therapeutic services that were often not being met. As such the 'Hope Agency' was born and its counselling team now offers counselling and therapeutic support throughout the UK.

Show comments

Find a therapist dealing with Separation and divorce

All therapists are verified professionals

All therapists are verified professionals