Navigating extremes: Psychological splitting

In a world that is bustling with rapid changes, tough decisions, and a tapestry of diverse perspectives, the concept of "splitting" often weaves its way into our lives. Splitting is like a mental tightrope walk, where we sometimes fall into the habit of seeing things, people, or even ourselves, in stark, black-and-white contrasts, failing to appreciate the rich spectrum of colours in between.


The development of psychological splitting

Splitting often emerges as a psychological defence mechanism – a coping strategy deeply rooted in our emotional responses and experiences. It can trace its origins to early childhood, where individuals may struggle to comprehend and reconcile the complexities of their environment. For some, early relationships with caregivers can shape this tendency, as they may have experienced extreme fluctuations in care and attention.

Splitting becomes a way to make sense of an unpredictable world, where people and situations are perceived as either entirely reliable or entirely unreliable. It's a way to manage the overwhelming emotions that can arise when facing contradictory experiences or emotions.

Over time, if this coping mechanism isn't addressed or adapted, it can persist into adulthood, shaping our perceptions and reactions in a black-and-white manner. Recognising and addressing this pattern is crucial for fostering emotional maturity and healthier relationships.

Unpacking the idea of splitting

Splitting is a cognitive distortion often associated with borderline personality disorder (BPD), but it can affect anyone, no matter their mental health status.

It is the tendency to view the world in extreme, all-or-nothing terms, resulting in perceptions that are often skewed, emotions that are intensified, and relationships that may bear the strain of our uncompromising judgments. It's like having a pair of mental binoculars that can only see the extremes.

The all-or-nothing conundrum

At the heart of splitting lies the all-or-nothing conundrum. It's the cognitive trap that pushes us to put everything in either the 'totally good' or 'absolutely bad' boxes, without acknowledging the myriad shades of grey that life presents. For instance, a friend might be the 'best' one day and the 'worst' the next, without us appreciating the intricate mosaic of qualities and imperfections that make them human.

Challenges posed by splitting

Splitting carries consequences that ripple through our lives. It can strain our personal relationships, lead us to impulsive decisions, drive erratic behaviour, and even cloud our ability to make sound judgments. What's more, it can cast a shadow on our self-esteem, especially when we find ourselves relegated to the 'all bad' category after making mistakes or facing setbacks.

Strategies for nurturing a balanced perspective

Overcoming splitting and fostering a more balanced perspective is an ongoing journey that calls for self-awareness, practice, and patience to navigate life's complexities. Here are some approaches that can help you chart a course toward balance:

1. Self-awareness: Spotting the split

The first step in taming splitting is to recognise when it rears its head. Keep an eye out for situations where you're inclined to paint things in stark extremes. By acknowledging that splitting is a cognitive distortion, you're already on the path to understanding the full picture.

2. Slow down and reflect

When you find yourself sliding into the all-or-nothing mindset, it's time to hit the brakes. Take a pause to reflect on the situation. Challenge yourself to explore the presence of various shades of grey and uncover the subtleties that can be easily overlooked.

3. Cultivate empathy

The art of empathy is a powerful antidote to splitting. Regardless of how others may let you down or fall short of your expectations, remember that every person is a multi-faceted individual, capable of both positive and negative actions. Practising empathy can help you see the depth of their humanity beyond surface judgements.

4. Question your assumptions

Make it a practice to question your assumptions and preconceived notions. Challenge yourself to seek out evidence that supports your extreme viewpoint, as well as evidence that contradicts it. Be open to the possibility that your initial judgments may not capture the full story.

5. Seek different perspectives

Engage in conversations with individuals who hold diverse viewpoints. Exposure to different perspectives can expand your understanding of various issues and reduce the inclination to label everything as purely 'good' or 'bad'.

6. Mindfulness and grounding techniques

Mindfulness practices, like meditation and deep breathing, can keep you rooted in the present moment, preventing impulsive thinking from gaining the upper hand. Grounding techniques can serve as your tether to reality when emotions surge.

7. Professional guidance

If you find that splitting has a significant impact on your life and relationships, it's worth considering the support of a mental health professional. Therapy, especially dialectical behaviour therapy (DBT), is known to be effective in addressing splitting and cultivating a more balanced perspective.

In a world teeming with unique individuals, complex issues, and multifaceted scenarios, embracing complexity is the key to personal growth and more meaningful relationships. Splitting may be a common cognitive distortion, but with self-awareness and practice, we can learn to transcend it.

By challenging our all-or-nothing thinking, we open ourselves up to the rich tapestry of the middle ground, where the true depth and beauty of life flourish. Life, after all, is rarely starkly black and white; it's a masterpiece painted with countless shades of grey.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author. All articles published on Counselling Directory are reviewed by our editorial team.

Share this article with a friend
Twickenham TW1 & Richmond TW9
Written by Natasha Kelly, BA (Hons) MBACP
Twickenham TW1 & Richmond TW9

Natasha is a counsellor based in London and online. Her passion lies in helping individuals build meaningful connections and foster strong rapport. With a deep understanding of human emotions and interpersonal dynamics, she has worked as a primary school teacher and as a freelance writer on mental health.

Show comments

Find a therapist dealing with Borderline personality disorder (BPD)

All therapists are verified professionals

All therapists are verified professionals