Breaking free from people-pleasing and discovering boundaries
Is helping others and always making ourselves available really so bad? Surely we are just being amenable and easygoing. It can even feel good to give people what they want, even when it doesn't suit us, right? Isn’t being selfless and helpful a good personal quality?
Of course, being kind and giving is great; it can make us feel valued and build self-worth. It even validates us for a time, but perhaps, after a while – a few years or even decades – people-pleasing can become exhausting. Our sense of self becomes buried under a mountain of giving others what they want instead of showing how we truly feel, and we manage a persona that can feel unrecognisable to us.
For some, it can feel like a slightly uncomfortable chair that gets more worn over time, but you keep putting up with it. To others, it can feel like smiling on the outside yet screaming on the inside. Sound familiar?
Of course, there are times in life when putting others first is necessary, such as when you're a caregiver, family member, or caring friend. Some situations require us to set aside our emotions temporarily. However, when we always put others first and try to please people in our relationships and interactions, we can lose our sense of who we are and what we need.
Finding a balance that lets us be authentic and true to ourselves seems to come naturally for some, but for others who have never learned to put themselves first, it can feel almost impossible.
How people-pleasing manifests
People-pleasing can sometimes develop in childhood or through difficult relationships, where it may have helped you feel safe, valued or loved. Acting in ways that achieved approval and validation from others might have felt safer than being yourself and seeking validation from within.
If showing emotion as a child was not accepted, ignored, or even chastised, we may have learned to hide our emotions and outwardly show what pleased our parents or caregivers. We may have been frightened but received no reassurance, felt sad or hurt but showed little empathy. Instead, our feelings and experiences may have been dismissed or met with anger, disappointment, or ridicule, which meant that the next time we felt those emotions, we perhaps shut down and hid them, masking them by being brave or showing happiness to gain validation.
Perhaps feeling loved as a child felt conditional and something that had to be earned. Being the quiet, sweet, funny, or easy child may have won affection or appeased an angry or abusive parent, even if that wasn't what you felt on the inside.
How does it serve us now?
Pleasing others and having limited boundaries can feel safe, which is very appealing when your brain or lived experience tells you that being yourself or having your own needs could be dangerous or make people dislike you.
People-pleasing is often a survival technique and stress response known as fawning and sits alongside:
- fight: the urge to confront the threat directly
- flight: the urge to run away from the danger
- freeze: being completely still, shutting down or unable to move.
That being said, our stress response is a vital component of being human, and we sometimes need it to switch on to keep us safe from harm. We may need to flee from danger, defend ourselves or appease someone to escape a threatening situation; however, we don't want it to remain activated and hinder our sense of self.
Many clients come into my therapy room who have adopted this safety behaviour in their day-to-day lives. Some recognise where it stems from but are unsure of how to make change, while others are at a loss as to why they feel so disconnected from themselves. Over time, this can contribute to feelings of anxiety, depression, dissociation and low self-worth.
A negative inner critic can question our every conversation and interaction, evaluating how we came across. Did we please? Did we give what was needed? All this inner energy may leave us feeling completely lost and burnt out, and we might find ourselves withdrawing from family and friends or offloading our frustration onto loved ones.
How can we make change?
Looking back on our childhood experiences and past relationships can be confronting, but it can also be a treasure trove of information that helps unearth why we think, react, or behave in certain ways. What messages were communicated to us growing up? How did we truly feel beneath the person we let the world see, and do those emotions still sit under the surface today?
This helps us to gain understanding and start to recognise our own needs and values, the parts of ourselves that have perhaps felt unimportant.
We can ask:
- What is stopping me from putting my own needs higher up on my list of priorities?
- How can I begin to set boundaries and start putting myself first?
- How do I recognise what's important to me and start to live in line with those values?
- Would I like to show my true self without feeling fear?
Working with a professional therapist is a safe, helpful way to better understand how life has shaped us. We may find that there are traumatic experiences we need to process or deep emotions we simply need to voice. This can help release and disarm what keeps us feeling unsafe.
We can then begin to look forward with more clarity and empowerment, helping us to connect our values to how we feel on the inside and how we show ourselves to others in ways that feel more balanced and authentic. We can explore how to start setting boundaries in a healthy and productive way, without overwhelming our stress response.
The therapy experience
There is no one-size-fits-all approach to therapy. Everyone’s life experiences are different, and a therapist should approach treatment collaboratively with each client. It is also important to note that past events which may remain a psychological threat for one person may not for the next.
We may downplay an experience because it didn’t seem that difficult compared to what some people go through, but somehow our mind wanders to it regularly. This can make us talk down our problems, believing we just need to get over them, but underneath, something sits uncomfortably and gets in the way of living.
There is no subject or experience too small, and even if it may never seem like a good time to begin therapy, taking that first step and making an enquiry can be a way to find that time for yourself, whether you are 18, 86 or beyond.
Find the right counsellor or therapist for you
All therapists are verified professionals