Counselling Directory
0
menumenu
Are you a counsellor? Log in Join us
Find a counsellor
  • Home
  • What's worrying you?
  • Getting help
    • What is counselling?
    • Types of therapy
    • FAQs
    • Find a counsellor or psychotherapist
    • Worried about someone else?
    • Not sure where to start?
    • Self-care
  • Articles
  • Events
  • Facts & Figures
  • News & Stories
    • Recent news
    • Your stories
Log inJoin us
Saved profiles (0)
  • Home>
  • Expert articles>
  • Integrative Psychotherapy as an Effective Form of Counselling

Integrative Psychotherapy as an Effective Form of Counselling

21st August, 20130 Comments

Integrative counselling and psychotherapy can be seen as one of the most effective approach form of counselling. Its strategies can be found in every successful form of therapy. The philosophical stance of this approach is that there is no single approach to psychological intervention that is suitable for every client; each person is unique and distinctive, which means that one-size fits all approaches to therapy will not be effective. As an individual, psychological distress varies from one person to another; hence relying on one approach of therapy alone will be difficult when treating many health conditions. Integrative counselling / psychotherapy can be classified into four segments including common factors, technical eclecticism, theoretical integration and assimilative integration. Which integration therapy are you using as a contemporary counsellor/psychotherapist?

Theoretical integration

Theoretical integration is the combination of two approaches with a common philosophy, which suggests that joining two theories would work more effectively than a single premise. The classic examples are cognitive analytical therapy which was derived from psychodynamic therapy and cognitive therapy and conceived by Anthony Ryle (1990); and Conversational Therapy developed by Hobson (1985). Cognitive behavioural therapy is part of the theoretical integration and Trans-theoretical approach developed by Prochaska & DiClemente (1994). One problem identified in theoretical integration is that it is difficult to integrate some theories; for instance, it is difficult to integrate psychodynamic theory and behavioural theory because of their distinctions in philosophies, ideas, concepts and assumptions. As an example, psychodynamic approach suggests that our early experiences from birth onwards and their impacts lead to our psychological problems. In contrast, behaviour theory sees problems as much more agreeable to change. The distinction between them would result in incompatiblities among the two theories.

Common factors

The aim of common factors approach is to look at the common tools available in each approach that can be useful in the therapy. There is no benchmark list of common factors; however, if a list were to be constructed, it absolutely would encompass the common factors. Irrespective of the approach a therapist will use in therapy it would include common factors. Common factors are unavoidable; they are:

  • The therapist/client rapport
  • The emotional release or catharsis
  • Therapist qualities such as attention, positive regards, empathy, congruence,
  • Confronting difficulties
  • Social skills training
  • Clarification
  • Desensitisation
  • Time as a precious element in counselling

Assimilative integration

In assimilative approach, the therapist sticks to one system of approach, for example Humanistic or psychodynamic, but the therapist will use strategies from other therapeutic approaches as well. A classic example is that a therapist may understand client in terms of cognitive theory because she finds this approach helpful in understanding what is going on in the process of the treatment. Nonetheless, the therapist may recall that there are strategies in some approaches that are not proposed by cognitive theory, but rather can work very effectively and contribute to the treatment or treatment plan. The cognitive therapist can use Gestalt therapy techniques like ‘‘increase awareness’’ to inhibit automatic thoughts. Gestalt theory says this is enough and you do not have to ‘‘do’’ anything to change; change will happen by itself once a client increases awareness. One of the functions of cognitive therapy is to try to bring automatic thoughts into awareness. Awareness is the first step towards change and better problem solving. Another classical example is behavioural therapist can deploy the Gestalt two-chairs dialogue.

Technical Eclecticism

In technical eclectics, the therapist looks at and selects the best interventions. The therapist habitually relies on experience and knowledge of what has worked in the past for others through theories and research literature to choose therapy suitable for the clients. Technical eclecticism shares similarities and differences with assimilative integration, but it has no theoretical underpinning to the approach. The similarities shared among assimilative integration and technical eclecticism are that both of them rely on a repertoire of therapeutic techniques, focusing on the wellbeing of clients rather than committing themselves to a particular school of thought of psychotherapy.

Related articles from our experts

Andrew Harvey Counsellor & Therapist, In Nottingham
From addiction to recovery

Andrew Harvey Counsellor & Therapist, In Nottingham

April 16th, 2018
Dahlian Kirby
How to be counselled - a beginners guide

Dahlian Kirby

April 7th, 2018
Marissa Walter Dip Therapeutic Counselling, MBACP (Reg) NCS (Accred Reg)
The value of counselling - what am I paying for?

Marissa Walter Dip Therapeutic Counselling, MBACP (Reg) NCS (Accred Reg)

April 5th, 2018
Can a relationship survive without intimacy?

Keeley Townsend BA (Hons), Ad.Dip.CP with Distinction, MNCS (Acc)

December 14th, 2009
Imi Lo: Psychotherapist, Art Therapist & Author (MMH,UKCP,HCPC,FRSA,MBPsS)
Why do I feel nothing? Emptiness and borderline personality

Imi Lo: Psychotherapist, Art Therapist & Author (MMH,UKCP,HCPC,FRSA,MBPsS)

March 29th, 2015
Andrew Harvey Counsellor & Therapist, In Nottingham
From addiction to recovery

Andrew Harvey Counsellor & Therapist, In Nottingham

April 16th, 2018

Counselling Directory is not responsible for the articles published by members. The views expressed are those of the member who wrote the article.

Share on: Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn
Find a counsellor or psychotherapist near you
Select multiple
Advanced search

print this pagePrint this page

Get involved Connect with us, we're social.
Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
More information
  • About us
  • Recommend us
  • Legal terms
  • Privacy/Cookies
  • Browse by region
  • Press centre
  • Find a supervisor
  • Links
  • Site map
  • Site help

Contact us

  • Counselling Directory, Building 3
  • Riverside Way, Camberley
  • Surrey, GU15 3YL
  • Membership Services Team:
    0333 325 2500 *
  • Contact us
Copyright © 2018 site by Memiah Limited

* Calls to 03 numbers cost the same as calling an 01 or 02 number and
count towards any inclusive minutes in the same way as 01 and 02 calls.

Healthy ideas that change the world

Get our free monthly e-magazine straight to your inbox

Find out more at happiful.com