Why did Freud see human nature as being motivated solely by instincts for pleasure?
Written by listed counsellor/psychotherapist: Steve Earlam. MSc. Dip HE. MNCS (Accd). MFDAP
Freud expressed the view that humans are primarily driven by sexual and aggressive instincts and that sexual and aggressive energy if not able to be expressed in a natural or direct way may be channelled into cultural activities such as art and science. The continuous pursuit of pleasure is not always acceptable with society.
Freud suggested that much of human behaviour is controlled by forces outside our awareness and the relationship between a person and society is controlled by primitive urges buried deep within our unconscious. Freud argued that most of our psychic energy is used in trying to find expressions of unconscious ideas that are acceptable, or failing that keeping them unconscious.
I think that at the time that Freud launched his findings upon the world that many students of behaviour found them to be radical and acceptable understandings of human behaviour. I am persuaded though to go with Frankl, I particularly find his explanation of a 'moment in time' between the stimulus and reaction when discussing 'man's search for meaning', as an explanation that can be transferred into practical application and certainly people I have worked with find it a positive way to apply good decision making, when confronting their own behaviour.
‘In between stimulus and response there is a space, in that space lies our power to choose our response in our response lies our growth and our freedom.”
Frankl is suggesting that while there are genetic factors to our mental, emotional and physical problems, there is often a moment in between when something triggers how we react. In that moment there is an opportunity to choose whether we survive or capitulate.
Related articles from our experts
Charlotte Thomas BACP registered, BA (hons), MSc, FCIPD, Ad.Dip.CP, MNCS (ACC)October 28th, 2015
Stephanie Cawthorn MA Dip Hip UKCP registered psychotherapistNovember 23rd, 2015
Andrea Harrn Psychotherapist and Author of The Mood CardsMay 13th, 2011
Jane Bronwyn HolderAugust 21st, 2013
Counselling Directory is not responsible for the articles published by members. The views expressed are those of the member who wrote the article.