A brief history of attachment based psychoanalytical psychotherapy
Written by listed counsellor/psychotherapist: Olga Gelfman-Gratwick UKCP
18th July, 2009
Freud’s legacy and the centrality of relationships
The formulation of Freud’s theory of instincts became increasingly rigid in the middle decades of the last century producing a dominant conception of individual development and of psychoanalytic psychotherapy as a process of creating adaptations of disruptive and dangerous drives.
In contrast Karen Horney and others, including Erich Fromm, Adolph Mayer, James S. Plant, Henry Stack Sullivan and Clara Thompson in the US and Ronald Fairbairn, Donald Winnicott, Marjorie Brierley, and John Bowlby in the UK were developing an understanding of human development based on the centrality of human relationships in their specific cultural contexts.
Much of Sigmund Freud’s work remains central. His work on the unconscious world, mourning, trauma, and the compulsion to repeat is fundamental. His use of free association, his development of working with transference and counter- transference, and his understanding of the meanings that might be drawn from symptoms and from dreams are essential to psychotherapeutic practice. His broadening of the conceptualisation of erotic life continues to provide vital insights into relationships and identities. Karen Horney was a pioneer in challenging patriarchal ideals and the devaluing of the female experience. Her feminist perspective presented a radical challenge to established cultural assumptions in the psychoanalytic world.
Trauma and abuse
The early years of the Karen Horney Association in the late seventies and early eighties coincided with a growing social awareness of the scale of the problem of child sexual abuse. Alice Miller’s prolific and highly accessible early writing broadened the understanding of child abuse to include emotional as well as physical abuse. Often the most profound aspect of all abuse is that the child is abandoned and left alone at times of great suffering and despair. Alice Miller proposed that having contacted the hurt child within the adult, the therapist aims to be an advocate for that person and encourages the process of mourning to enable healing to take place.
The idea of being an advocate for the child within struck a chord with Karen Horney’s idea of psychoanalysis as an assisted self-analysis - ideas also developed by Theodore Reik. In 1989 the organisation was reformed as the Institute of Self-Analysis and the training was launched. For a time therapists were referred to as advocates. The idea is of great value in the respect it shows towards the individual coming into therapy and in the sense that the nurturing of the emergent self of the client is the task of psychotherapy.
On the other hand the idea of the emergent self has its problems. Karen Horney herself had described how the client and the therapist might understand things very differently.
“Although both may talk in terms of evolution, growth, development, they mean entirely different things. The analyst has in mind the growth of the real self; the patient can only think of perfecting his ideal self” (Neurosis and Human Growth, 1950). This demands a deeper understanding of how individuals are formed in relationship and how that can be explored in later life. This required a revisiting of psychoanalytic ideas on the transference and the counter-transference, on the negative transference and the erotic transference. It also required rethinking ideas about the formation of the self and the de-centred self.
The dominant themes: rejection of classical drive theory, emphasis on the importance of environmental factors – particularly relationships, the crucial place of mourning, the link between attachment, security and exploration, all contributed to the development of an attachment-based psychoanalytic psychotherapy.
Although attachment theory is now becoming very widely accepted, for many years it was rejected by the dominant stream of British psychoanalysis strongly influenced by Melanie Klein. Klein had by degrees reworked drive theory from the classical model and had like, Karen Horney, mounted an important challenge to the phallocentric bias in Freud’s theorising. Bowlby trained with her and followed her in focussing on the earliest years of life and the relationship with mother. He separated from her over the absolute importance she attached to the inner world.
Attachment theory is a response to the need to develop new approaches to the relationship between the psychological and the biological. It addresses this in a limited and pragmatic way, inviting further exploration. This approach fits much more readily to the state of scientific development in this field. Neuro-psychobiological study of the brain and the understanding of the interaction of neural development with psychological development are rapidly evolving. This is an exciting area of controversy and investigation.
Multiple points of view
The new approach emphasises the importance of studying the same phenomena from many points of view. The claim of the clinical encounter to be a method of scientific enquiry can only be sustained if there is a willingness to relate the data gathered and the theoretical perspectives proposed to other forms of enquiry. Bowlby was most concerned to make links with academic research and ethology.
Attachment researchers established two crucial methods linking psychoanalytic theorising and psychological research. Mary Ainsworth developed the Strange Situation Test as a method of study of the attachment patterns of early life. Mary Main developed the Adult Attachment Interview as a method of enquiry into the attachment patterns of adults. Another vital contribution has come from observational studies of infants. .
The Internal World
Bowlby was concerned about the need for care in theorising in the internal world. Towards the end of the volume on Attachment (the first of the trilogy Attachment, Separation and Loss) he referred to these “profound questions” and the “giant controversies” and recognised how much research is still needed (Bowlby, 1969).
Attachment based psychoanalytical psychotherapy has drawn on a wide range of approaches including the British object relations school, the American interpersonalist school, theories on the development of the self, and contemporary work on trauma and dissociation to provide a breadth and depth of insight into the structure and dynamics of the internal world. The common themes that run through them all are the importance of unconscious communication, of the transference and the counter-transference, of containment and the acceptance of difference, and an emphasis on two person psychology.
Related articles from our experts
Jacqueline Karaca M.Sc. Hons Counselling Psych; MBACP Reg.November 20th, 2017
Anna Bassett BA (hons) MBACPNovember 14th, 2017
Anna Jezuita (MBACP) Relationship Reconciliation,Counselling, MindfulnessNovember 6th, 2017
Andrea Harrn Psychotherapist and Author of The Mood CardsMay 13th, 2011
Imi Lo: Psychotherapist, Art Therapist, Supervisor (MMH,UKCP,HCPC,MBPsS)March 29th, 2015
Keeley Townsend BA (Hons), Ad.Dip.CP with Distinction, MNCS (Acc)December 14th, 2009
Counselling Directory is not responsible for the articles published by members. The views expressed are those of the member who wrote the article.